Talarico's Pizzeria West Seattle - Authentic, Generous Slices & Fresh Local Ingredients

I used to come here all the time when I lived in West Seattle a few years ago, but this was my first time back since I moved south. I'm pleased to say the pizza was still really good, and yeah the slices are still as big as advertised! We came for a post wedding rehearsal dinner and our servers were very attentive and nice, and made for a fun experience. Also, get the Starburst Margarita - it's unfortunately misnamed, because it tastes EXACTLY like a watermelon Jolly Rancher!

This place is huge! The vibe here is very relaxed. We really enjoyed the songs they were playing when we visited. We ordered melina mocktail, italian house salad, slice of drunken sicilian and west side. The salad had a mild dressing that we liked a lot. The mocktail was really sour but it started to taste better later when the ice melted some more. The pizza slices were big and they offered to cut it in pieces. They tasted fresh and were delicious. We really enjoyed our time here.

Pizza slices are huge. One piece per person is plenty. All the options were great. Crust is on point.

The food is made from local ingredients and was excellent. The mozzarella balls were fantastic and the slices of pizza were larger than some entire pizzas I've had elsewhere. The staff were lovely, the atmosphere was lovely but not too loud and the prices are super reasonable for the very high quality you get. We'll be back.

Stopped in for lunch and grabbed a seat at the bar. I had a slice, a salad, and an adult beverage; everything hit the spot. I’ve been coming here for years, and it’s always been a solid go-to. The food still tastes good, though I do think it had a little more of that wow factor when the place first opened. Before this spot, I remember the Chinese restaurant that used to be here, New Luck Toy. That was a great place with its own charm. Still, it’s nice to see this space continue to be a neighborhood favorite.

This place has the BEST pizza! The portion size is massive and it’s really bang for your buck. I’ve been here multiple times, but love the Al Pastor the most! The Tiramisu is also a notable mention.

We took up one corner of the restaurant for a birthday party, the staff was very accommodating, gracious and professional. The food was really good. I especially enjoyed the potato nachos. Tyrone was the waiter assigned to our rather large party, he kept us all happy and well taken care of. Never missed a beat. A smooth operation altogether. We enjoyed the entire experience.

Stopped in with friends for a birthday. Accommodating staff and GREAT pizza. The HUGE 13 in slices are well worth the $9.99/ea. We will definitely come back here if we're ever looking for food in the area.